Skip to content

Business emailVersus

ProtonMail vs Gmail: What You Give Up (and Gain) by Switching

ProtonMail vs Gmail compared on encryption, price, storage, custom domains and migration, with Fastmail as the middle option. Vendor-stated facts only.

Disclosure: we may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and never decides a verdict or an EDGE mark. How we make money.

A hand holding craft envelopes on a stylish marble table with pencils, showcasing an artistic layout.
Photo: kaboompics / Pexels

Verdict

Verdict

Pick Proton Mail if you want a mailbox the provider can’t read: stored mail uses zero-access encryption and mail between Proton users is end-to-end encrypted3. Pick Gmail or Google Workspace if you want 15 GB free instead of 1 GB and Google’s suite, knowing that Google’s provider-unreadable client-side encryption is limited to editions such as Enterprise Plus8110.

Proton MailBest for people and small teams who want mail stored so the provider can't read it
Gmail (Google Workspace)Best for teams that want the most free storage and Google's office suite, and accept provider-side encryption

Head-to-head

Proton Mail vs Gmail (Google Workspace), criterion by criterion

CriterionProton MailGmail (Google Workspace)
Business starting price (per user/mo)27 Mail Essentials $6.99, billed $83.88 every 12 months Business Starter $7 with a 1-year commitment ($8.40 flexible)
Free plan storage18 Up to 1 GB 15 GB shared across Gmail, Drive and PhotosEdge
Mail stored so the provider can't read it310 Zero-access encryption on every messageEdge Client-side encryption on Enterprise Plus, Frontline Plus, Education Standard and Plus only
Mail between two users of the same service39 End-to-end encryptedEdge TLS in transit
Mail to outside addresses39 TLS by default; end-to-end with password-protected email or PGP TLS on all messages; S/MIME on work or school accounts
Custom domain1267 Paid plans only: 1 domain on Mail Plus, 3 on Mail Essentials Through Google Workspace, from Business Starter
Storage on the entry business plan27 15 GB per user 30 GB pooled per userEdge
Moving in from the other side47 Easy Switch imports Gmail mail, contacts and calendars with ongoing sync Workspace Migrate tool listed on Business Standard

EDGE marks the side the cited facts favor on that row. No mark means the facts don't clearly favor either side. Numbers after a criterion point to its sources.

Proton Mail

From Free (1 GB); Mail Plus $3.99/mo billed annually at $47.88 after a first-year offer · checked

Visit Proton Mail (opens in a new tab)

Gmail (Google Workspace)

From Free (15 GB shared); Workspace Business Starter $7/user/mo with a 1-year commitment · checked

Visit Gmail (Google Workspace) (opens in a new tab)
Feature matrixEncryption, storage and switching at a glance
FeatureProton MailGmail / Google WorkspaceFastmail
Stored mail the provider can't read YesEnterprise Plus and select editionsEncrypted at rest, not E2E
Free plan1 GB15 GB, shared30-day trial only
Custom domain on cheapest paid plan YesWorkspace plansNot on Basic
Gmail import with ongoing sync YesNot applicable Yes

What Proton, Google and Fastmail state on their own pricing and help pages. Google’s client-side encryption needs an eligible Workspace edition.

Sources: [1] [3] [4] [6] [8] [10] [12] [13] [14] · checked 2026-11-20Download image

ProtonMail vs Gmail comes down to one trade. Proton Mail stores your mail so that Proton itself can’t read it3. Gmail gives you 15 times the free storage and Google’s whole suite, but its mail is encrypted in transit rather than locked away from the provider, unless you pay for an edition with client-side encryption8910. Prices are close on business plans. Storage and encryption are not.

We haven’t used these services in a lab for this piece. Every figure comes from Proton’s, Google’s or Fastmail’s own pages, checked on 2026-11-20. Our method is on how we compare, and our editorial policy explains how affiliate links work here.

The verdict

  • Pick Proton Mail if the point of switching is that your email provider shouldn’t be able to read your mail. Zero-access storage is the default on every plan, including free3.
  • Pick Gmail or Google Workspace if you need generous free storage, Docs and Drive in one admin console, or more than 15 GB of mail on a starter business plan78.
  • Look at Fastmail if you mostly want to leave Google, want a conventional paid mailbox that works with apps like Outlook and iPhone Mail, and don’t need end-to-end encryption1213.

ProtonMail vs Gmail: the encryption model

This is the real difference, so it’s worth being precise about what each vendor claims.

Proton Mail. Proton says all messages in your inbox are stored with zero-access encryption, which it describes as meaning no one else can read them, including Proton3. Messages between Proton addresses are end-to-end encrypted in transit3. There are two limits Proton states itself. First, mail to other providers “isn’t end-to-end encrypted by default”; it travels over TLS, and you can add end-to-end encryption with a password-protected email or PGP3. Second, subject lines are not end-to-end encrypted, because OpenPGP keeps them in an unencrypted header3. Proton adds that reaching subject lines would take a court order approved by a Swiss judge3.

Gmail. Google says all Gmail messages use TLS automatically, and a red open lock marks a message that arrived unencrypted9. S/MIME is available for work or school accounts9. Google’s provider-unreadable option is client-side encryption, which it describes as encryption “that Google servers and third parties can’t decrypt”10. It’s limited to Frontline Plus, Enterprise Plus, Education Standard and Education Plus10. Enterprise has no public price on the Workspace pricing page7, so small teams on Business Starter, Standard or Plus don’t get it.

Google also says Gmail does not scan or read your messages to show you ads, though free Gmail does show ads based on your signed-in activity11.

Pricing

On paper the business plans cost about the same.

Plan Price Storage
Proton Free $0 Up to 1 GB
Proton Mail Plus $47.88/yr renewal ($4.99 month to month) 15 GB
Proton Mail Essentials $6.99/user/mo, billed $83.88 yearly 15 GB/user
Proton Workspace Standard $14.99/user/mo regular 1 TB/user
Gmail (free) $0 15 GB, shared
Workspace Business Starter $7/user/mo, 1-year commitment 30 GB pooled/user
Workspace Business Standard $14/user/mo, 1-year commitment 2 TB pooled/user
Workspace Business Plus $22/user/mo, 1-year commitment 5 TB pooled/user

Sources: Proton12, Google78.

Both vendors were running promotions when we checked. Proton showed Mail Plus at $29.88 for the first 12 months, renewing at $47.881, and 40% off the first year of Workspace Standard and Premium for new customers with up to 10 users, ending November 30, 20262. Google showed up to 50% off the first 3 months for new customers, and its flexible (no annual commitment) Business Starter price was $8.407. Budget on the renewal prices.

Both offer trials: Proton’s business plans list a 14-day free trial and a 30-day money-back guarantee2, and Google lists 14 days at no cost7.

ChartEntry business plan with a custom domain
  • Fastmail Standard $5/user/mo billed annually
  • Proton Mail Essentials $6.99/user/mo billed annually
  • Google Workspace Business Starter $7/user/mo, 1-year commitment

Bars scaled from 0

Per user per month. Fastmail Standard and Proton Mail Essentials are billed annually; Google Workspace Business Starter is billed monthly on a 1-year commitment. Regular prices, not first-term offers.

Sources: [2] [7] [12] · checked 2026-11-20Download image

Storage

Free storage is where Gmail clearly wins. Every Google Account gets 15 GB, “shared across Gmail, Google Drive, and Google Photos”8. Proton Free gives up to 1 GB1.

Paid, it depends on the tier. Proton Mail Plus and Mail Essentials both give 15 GB12; Business Starter gives 30 GB of pooled storage per user7. At the next step up the two converge in scale: Proton Workspace Standard has 1 TB per user2 and Google Business Standard has 2 TB pooled per user7.

Head-to-headFree storage

Free storage

Proton Mail Free

1 GB

Gmail (Google Account)Edge

15 GB

Proton Free storage versus the free storage every Google Account gets, shared across Gmail, Drive and Photos.

Sources: [1] [8] · checked 2026-11-20Download image

Custom domains

Proton’s help page lists a paid plan as the requirement for a custom domain: “All paid plans support adding custom domains”6. Mail Plus supports 1 domain, Proton Unlimited and Mail Essentials 3, Workspace Standard 15 and Workspace Premium 2012.

Google’s route to you@yourcompany.com is Google Workspace, which lists “secure custom business email” from Business Starter up7.

Business features beyond the inbox

Once you pay per user, both vendors sell a suite rather than a mailbox, and the line-ups now look alike.

Proton. Mail Essentials covers email and calendar, appointment scheduling, cloud storage with file sharing, a document and spreadsheet editor and migration from “Big Tech”2. Every business plan lists a catch-all address, automatic forwarding, password-protected emails and unlimited filters, folders and labels2. Workspace Standard adds video meetings for 100 participants, a VPN with ad-blocking and a password manager with team vaults2. Workspace Premium adds 250-participant meetings, the Lumo AI chat, an email writing assistant and data retention policies2.

Google. Business Starter includes custom business email, the Gemini assistant in Gmail and 100-participant video meetings7. Business Standard adds meeting recording, 150 participants, appointment booking pages and eSignature7. Business Plus adds Vault “to retain, archive, and search data,” eDiscovery, secure LDAP and 500-participant meetings7.

If retention and legal holds matter, compare Proton Workspace Premium’s data retention policies2 with Google’s Vault on Business Plus7; neither is on the entry tier.

On the personal side, Proton Mail Plus includes 10 addresses and 10 hide-my-email aliases, and Proton Unlimited raises that to 15 extra addresses and unlimited aliases with 500 GB and Proton’s VPN and password manager bundled in1.

What you give up

Leaving Gmail for Proton, you give up free storage (15 GB down to 1 GB)18 and, on the free plan, desktop email apps: Proton Mail Bridge, which connects Outlook, Thunderbird and Apple Mail, needs a paid plan5. You also accept that subject lines and mail to non-Proton contacts aren’t end-to-end encrypted unless you take extra steps3. Proton’s business plans do list SMTP access and support for Outlook, Thunderbird and Apple Mail2.

Staying on Gmail, you give up provider-unreadable storage unless you buy an eligible edition10, and on free Gmail you keep seeing ads11. Starter, Standard and Plus are also capped at 300 users7.

Where Fastmail fits

Fastmail product image
Fastmail (image: fastmail.com)

Fastmail is the middle option for people who want off Google but don’t need Proton’s encryption model. Fastmail says plainly: “We don’t offer end-to-end encryption in our own apps”13. Data is stored encrypted on disk and encrypted in transit, PGP or S/MIME work through third-party apps, and you choose EU or USA as your primary data location13.

Pricing is simple. Individual is $5 a month billed annually ($60 for 12 months) or $6 month to month, with 60 GB and your own domains12. For teams, Standard is $5 per user per month billed annually with 60 GB and custom domains, and Professional is $9 with 150 GB; the $3 Basic plan doesn’t include custom domains12. Every plan has a free trial of up to 30 days, but there’s no free plan12.

Try Fastmail

Which should you pick?

  • You want your provider unable to read your stored mail, without an enterprise contract: Proton Mail. Start free, then move to Mail Plus or Mail Essentials when you add a domain123.
  • You run your company on Docs, Drive and Meet and need 2 TB per user: Google Workspace Business Standard7.
  • You need Google with client-side encryption: talk to Google about Enterprise Plus10.
  • You want a paid inbox that works with third-party apps like Outlook and iPhone Mail, and don’t need end-to-end encryption: Fastmail Standard1213.

Try Proton Mail

Migration notes

Gmail to Proton. Easy Switch imports messages, calendars and contacts “in one click,” and for Gmail it sets up an ongoing connection so new mail keeps arriving in Proton automatically4. Easy Switch is included on every plan, including free1. Leave that sync running until your contacts have your new address.

Gmail to Fastmail. Fastmail imports mail, calendars and contacts from Gmail, and you can choose to keep fetching mail from your Gmail account14. Each Gmail label becomes a folder, so a message with several labels lands in several folders14.

Proton or anything else to Google. Google lists its Workspace Migrate tool on Business Standard7.

Whichever way you move, keep the old account open until the sync has caught up and your important senders have switched.

Strengths and limits

Strengths and limits

Best for people and small teams who want mail stored so the provider can't read itFrom Free (1 GB); Mail Plus $3.99/mo billed annually at $47.88 after a first-year offer · checked 2026-11-20

Proton Mail product image
Proton Mail (image: proton.me)

Strengths

  • Zero-access encryption on every stored message
  • End-to-end encryption between Proton addresses by default
  • Easy Switch imports Gmail mail, contacts and calendars with ongoing sync
  • Custom domains on every paid plan, from Mail Plus up

Limits

  • Free plan has up to 1 GB of storage
  • Subject lines are not end-to-end encrypted
  • Mail to non-Proton addresses is not end-to-end encrypted by default
  • Desktop email apps via Bridge need a paid plan

Best for teams that want the most free storage and Google's office suite, and accept provider-side encryptionFrom Free (15 GB shared); Workspace Business Starter $7/user/mo with a 1-year commitment · checked 2026-11-20

Gmail (Google Workspace) product image
Gmail (Google Workspace) (image: workspace.google.com)

Strengths

  • 15 GB free, shared across Gmail, Drive and Photos
  • Business Starter includes 30 GB pooled storage per user and custom business email
  • TLS on all Gmail messages
  • Business Standard adds 2 TB per user and the Workspace Migrate tool

Limits

  • Client-side encryption only on Enterprise Plus, Frontline Plus and Education Standard/Plus
  • Free Gmail shows ads
  • Starter, Standard and Plus are capped at 300 users

FAQ

Questions people ask

Is Proton Mail more private than Gmail?

By design, yes. Proton stores every message with zero-access encryption, which it says means no one else, including Proton, can read it3. Gmail encrypts mail in transit with TLS9; Google offers client-side encryption that its servers can’t decrypt only on editions such as Enterprise Plus10.

Does Proton Mail encrypt email I send to Gmail users?

Not end to end by default. Mail to other providers is protected by TLS in transit; for end-to-end encryption you send a password-protected email or use PGP3.

Can I use my own domain with Proton Mail or Gmail?

Proton supports custom domains on all paid plans: 1 on Mail Plus, 3 on Proton Unlimited and Mail Essentials126. With Google, custom business email comes with Google Workspace, starting at Business Starter7.

How do I move from Gmail to Proton Mail?

Proton’s Easy Switch connects to your Gmail account, imports messages, calendars and contacts, and keeps new Gmail mail arriving in Proton automatically4. It’s included on the free plan too1.

Does Gmail read my email to show ads?

Google says Gmail does not scan or read your messages to show you ads, but free Gmail does display ads based on your signed-in activity11.

Where does Fastmail fit between them?

Fastmail is a paid middle option: $5 a month billed annually for 60 GB and custom domains12. It encrypts data at rest and in transit but doesn’t offer end-to-end encryption in its own apps13.

Sources

Sources

Small numbers in the text, like 1, point here. Each source shows the date we last checked it.

  1. 1Proton Mail plans and pricingproton.me
  2. 2Proton for Business plans and pricingproton.me
  3. 3Proton Mail encryption explainedproton.me
  4. 4Proton Easy Switchproton.me
  5. 5Proton Mail Bridgeproton.me
  6. 6Proton support: how to add a custom domainproton.me
  7. 7Google Workspace pricingworkspace.google.com
  8. 8Google One Help: how storage workssupport.google.com
  9. 9Gmail Help: email encryption in transitsupport.google.com
  10. 10Google Workspace Admin Help: about client-side encryptionknowledge.workspace.google.com
  11. 11Gmail Help: how Gmail ads worksupport.google.com
  12. 12Fastmail pricingfastmail.com
  13. 13Fastmail securityfastmail.com
  14. 14Fastmail Help: migrate to Fastmail from Gmailfastmail.help

Updated . See something out of date? Tell us and we will check it against the vendor's page.

Researched and written by

Alan Taylor

Related

All comparisons

More business email comparisons are on the way. See how we pick what to cover.