Password managersVersus
Proton Pass vs 1Password: Privacy-First Newcomer or Polished Incumbent?
Proton Pass vs 1Password: prices at every tier, email aliases, open source, the encryption model, sharing, SSO and passkeys, from each vendor's own pages.
Disclosure: we may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and never decides a verdict or an EDGE mark. How we make money.
Verdict
Verdict
Pick Proton Pass if privacy and price lead: it has a real free plan, built-in hide-my-email aliases and open-source apps, and its paid tiers list for less than 1Password’s125. Pick 1Password if you want the more established toolset, like Travel Mode, item links to anyone with expiry controls and a 128-bit Secret Key8910.
Head-to-head
Proton Pass vs 1Password, criterion by criterion
| Criterion | Proton Pass | 1Password |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan13 | Yes: unlimited logins and devices, 10 aliases, 2 vaults1Edge | None; 14-day free trial3 |
| Individual plan (per month, billed annually)13 | Pass Plus $1.99 for the first 12 months, then $35.88 a year1Edge | Individual $2.99 for new customers’ first year, then $3.993 |
| Family plan (per month, billed annually)13 | Pass Family $2.79 for up to 6 people for 12 months, then $59.88 a year1Edge | Families $4.49 for 5 people in the first year, then $5.993 |
| Business plans (billed annually)24 | Pass Essentials $1.99/user/mo, no SSO; Pass Professional $4.99/user/mo with SSO and SCIM; 3-user minimum2Edge | Teams Starter Pack $24.95/mo for up to 10 members; Business $8.99/user/mo4 |
| Email aliases1347 | 10 on Free; unlimited on Plus, with custom domains17Edge | Not listed on its plan pages34 |
| Sharing139 | Plus: vaults shared with up to 10 people, plus secure link sharing. Free: vaults shared with 21 | Families: unlimited shared vaults. Any plan: item links to anyone, with expiry and email limits39 |
| Passkeys111 | Supported on all devices, Free plan included1 | Save and sign in from the browser and iOS 17; passkey unlock in beta for new Individual accounts11 |
| Encryption model458 | AES-256-GCM vault keys, OpenPGP for sharing; usernames, web addresses and metadata encrypted5 | AES-256 end to end; key built from account password plus a 128-bit Secret Key48 |
| Code and jurisdiction45 | All apps open source; Swiss company, public audit reports5 | Independent third-party audits and SOC 2 Type II listed4 |
| Travel mode110 | Not listed on its plan pages1 | Vaults not marked safe for travel are removed from devices until you turn it off10Edge |
EDGE marks the side the cited facts favor on that row. No mark means the facts don't clearly favor either side. Numbers after a criterion point to its sources.
Proton Pass
From Free; Pass Plus $1.99/mo for the first 12 months, billed annually · checked
Visit Proton Pass (opens in a new tab)1Password
From $3.99/mo billed annually ($2.99 first year for new customers) · checked
Visit 1Password (opens in a new tab)Proton Pass vs 1Password is a choice between two philosophies. Proton Pass is the privacy-first option: a free tier, built-in email aliases, open-source apps and a Swiss company behind it156. 1Password is the polished incumbent, with a second secret built into its encryption, Travel Mode, and sharing and admin tools that cover a lot of edge cases8910. Proton also costs less at every tier we compared1234.
We didn’t test either product for this article. Every price and feature comes from the vendors’ own pages, checked on 2026-11-20, and how we compare explains how we mark an edge.
Proton Pass vs 1Password: the short verdict
Pick Proton Pass if:
- You want a free plan that works on every device1.
- You want a separate email alias for every sign-up17.
- You care that the app code is open and the company sits under Swiss law5.
- You’re buying for a small team and the per-seat price matters2.
Try Proton Pass. Paid plans carry a 30-day money-back guarantee1.
Pick 1Password if:
- You share logins with people outside your account and want expiring links9.
- You cross borders with sensitive vaults10.
- You’d rather rely on a Secret Key than on your password alone8.
Try 1Password free for 14 days3.
Pricing at every tier
All figures are per month, billed annually, in USD. Both vendors were running first-year promotions when we checked, so the table shows both the first-year price and what you pay after.
| Plan | Proton Pass | 1Password |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0, unlimited logins and devices1 | None; 14-day trial3 |
| One person | Pass Plus $1.99 for 12 months, then $35.88 a year1 | Individual $2.99 for the first year, then $3.993 |
| Family | Pass Family $2.79 for up to 6, then $59.88 a year1 | Families $4.49 for 5 people, then $5.993 |
| Small team | Pass Essentials $1.99/user, 3 to 30 users2 | Teams Starter Pack $24.95 for up to 10 members4 |
| Business | Pass Professional $4.99/user2 | Business $8.99/user4 |
The renewal prices are the ones to budget for. Pass Plus renews at $35.88 a year and Pass Family at $59.88 a year1. 1Password returns to $3.99 and $5.99 a month after the first year3. 1Password’s promotion applies only when you buy direct from 1Password.com, not through an app store3.
Proton also sells Proton Unlimited. It bundles Pass with Mail, Calendar, VPN and Drive for $6.49/mo in the first 12 months, renewing at $119.88 a year1. If you’d pay for a VPN or private email anyway, that bundle changes the maths.
Proton Pass review: what each plan gets you
Proton Free covers the basics:
- Unlimited logins, notes and cards on unlimited devices1
- 10 aliases and 2 vaults, with each vault shared with up to 2 people1
- Passkey support, 1 GB of storage, and no built-in 2FA codes1
Pass Plus adds:
- Unlimited aliases, with your own domain1
- 50 vaults, each shared with up to 10 people, plus secure link sharing1
- A built-in 2FA authenticator, dark web monitoring and Emergency Access1
- File attachments, 10 GB of storage and a CLI1
- Proton Sentinel, which Proton describes as AI systems plus analysts working around the clock to block suspicious logins15
Bars scaled from 0
Per month, billed annually13. First-year prices are promotions for new customers. Proton’s renewal is $35.88 every 12 months, shown here divided by 12.
Sources: [1] [3] · checked 2026-11-20Download image
Privacy: aliases, open source and jurisdiction
This is where Proton’s angle shows.
A hide-my-email alias is a random address that forwards mail to your real inbox. You can reply from the alias, use your own domain for aliases, and switch an alias off if it starts getting spam7. Proton Free includes 10 aliases and Pass Plus includes unlimited aliases1. Neither of 1Password’s pricing pages lists email aliases34.
Proton says all Proton Pass apps are open source, that independent experts have audited it and the reports are public, and that it runs a bug bounty5. The company is based in Geneva6. Proton says Swiss law stops it from handing the limited data it holds to foreign authorities, and that it can’t decrypt vault data anyway5.
1Password’s plan pages point to independent third-party audits and SOC 2 Type II certification4. They say nothing about open-source apps or about jurisdiction.
| Feature | Proton Pass | 1Password |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Yes | No |
| Built-in email aliases | Yes, 10 free | Not listed |
| Open-source apps | All apps | Not stated |
| Travel mode | Not listed | Yes |
| Item link sharing | Pass Plus | Any plan, with expiry |
| Command line tool | Pass Plus | Yes |
What each vendor lists on its own plan and feature pages135910.
Sources: [1] [3] [5] [9] [10] · checked 2026-11-20Download image
Security model
Both encrypt your vault on your device. They differ in what they emphasise.
Proton gives each vault a random 32-byte key and encrypts it with AES-256-GCM. The vault key is protected with OpenPGP (Curve25519), which is also how sharing works5. Proton says it encrypts usernames, web addresses and note contents along with passwords, and protects metadata too5.
1Password encrypts everything in your vaults end to end with AES-256, item titles and URLs included34. Its distinguishing feature is the Secret Key: a 34-character code with 128 bits of entropy, created on your device. It’s combined with your account password to form the encryption key, and neither secret is sent to 1Password. Someone who copies 1Password’s servers can’t decrypt your data without your Secret Key8. The cost is one more thing to keep safe, since 1Password can’t recover it for you8.
Proton’s extra layer sits at sign-in rather than in the encryption. Proton Sentinel is meant to stop malicious logins “even if an attacker has the correct password”5.
Sharing and families
1Password is more flexible here. You can send a link to a copy of any item to someone with no 1Password account. You choose when the link expires and can limit it to named email addresses; business accounts can limit it to a domain9. Families gets unlimited shared vaults and 5 guest accounts3.
Proton’s free plan shares vaults with up to 2 people and can’t share single items. Pass Plus raises vault sharing to 10 people per vault and adds secure link sharing1. Pass Family covers up to 6 accounts against 1Password Families’ 513.
On the family plans themselves, the two look closer than the prices suggest. Pass Family gives each member a full Pass Plus account, adds an admin panel for the family, and lists 50 GB of storage1. 1Password Families lets the organiser add, remove and recover members, and gives each person 1 GB of storage3. That member recovery matters when someone in the house forgets their password, and 1Password lists it on its pricing page3. Proton’s pricing page lists Emergency Access on its paid plans instead, but doesn’t describe member recovery1.
Business: SSO, SCIM and admin
At the business tier, the price gap is wide.
Proton’s Pass Essentials ($1.99/user/mo) is for 3 to 30 users. It includes item and link sharing, 2FA, dark web monitoring and unlimited aliases, but no SSO, no file attachments and no CLI2.
Pass Professional ($4.99/user/mo) adds:
- SSO and SCIM2
- Activity logs and enterprise policies2
- SIEM integration, group sharing, the CLI and an SSH agent2
Both Proton plans need at least 3 users and come with a 14-day trial2.
1Password Business ($8.99/user/mo) connects to Okta, Entra ID, OneLogin and Duo. It provisions users from Azure AD, Google Workspace, Okta, OneLogin, Rippling and JumpCloud, and streams events to Splunk, Elastic, Sumo Logic and Panther4. Staff can unlock with SSO through OpenID Connect providers including Google, JumpCloud and Ping Identity13.
Its business page also lists custom groups, usage reports, and a free Families plan for each user’s personal use4. For teams of 10 or fewer, the Teams Starter Pack is a flat $24.95/mo4. That’s below Pass Professional’s per-seat price once you pass 5 users, but it doesn’t include identity-provider integrations24.
Per user per month, billed annually, as listed today24. Proton shows its price as a discount and requires at least 3 users.
Sources: [2] [4] · checked 2026-11-20Download image
Passkeys, travel and day-to-day polish
Proton says passkeys work on all devices, Free plan included1. 1Password saves and signs in with passkeys from the browser and on iOS 17, and lets you share them through shared vaults. Unlocking 1Password itself with a passkey is in public beta for new Individual accounts11.
Travel Mode is the clearest 1Password-only feature in this comparison. You mark the vaults that are safe to carry and turn Travel Mode on. Every other vault disappears from your laptop, phone and browser extension until you turn it off10. Proton’s plan pages don’t list an equivalent1.
Both run on the usual platforms:
- Proton Pass: iOS, Android, Windows, macOS, Linux, a web app and browser extensions6
- 1Password: macOS, iOS, watchOS, Windows, Android and Linux, with extensions for Chrome, Safari, Edge, Firefox and Brave3
For developers, 1Password lists SSH workflows, Git commit signing, a CLI and SDKs3. Proton offers a CLI from Pass Plus up, and an SSH agent on Pass Professional12.
Which should you pick?
- You want it free: Proton Pass. 1Password has no free plan13.
- You sign up for many services and hate spam: Proton Pass, for the aliases17.
- You’re a family on a budget: Proton Pass Family. It covers 6 people at $2.79/mo for the first year1.
- You share with clients or contractors, or travel with sensitive data: 1Password, for expiring item links and Travel Mode910.
- You’re a company that needs SSO: shortlist both. Pass Professional costs $4.99/user/mo and 1Password Business costs $8.9924. Choose on directory support and admin depth, not price alone.
Moving from 1Password to Proton Pass
Proton’s import guide covers the move:
- Export a 1PUX file from the 1Password desktop app. On a Mac that’s File > Export; on Windows it’s the ☰ menu > Export. On iOS, go to Settings > Advanced.
- In the Proton Pass browser extension, open Settings > Import and choose “1Password (1pux, 1pif)”.
- Drop in the file12.
Proton’s guide doesn’t say whether passkeys or attachments come across12, so check those items after the import. The export file holds your vault’s contents, so delete it once you’re done.
Proton’s importer also lists LastPass, Bitwarden, Keeper and other managers14. If you’re on LastPass and deciding whether to leave, our LastPass vs 1Password comparison covers the 2022 breach and the switch. Our editorial policy explains how affiliate links work.
Strengths and limits
Strengths and limits
Proton Pass
Visit Proton Pass (opens in a new tab)
Strengths
- Free plan with unlimited logins, unlimited devices and 10 email aliases [S1]
- Unlimited hide-my-email aliases on Pass Plus, with your own domain [S1, S7]
- All apps are open source; Proton is based in Switzerland [S5, S6]
- Pass Professional adds SSO and SCIM at $4.99/user/mo, billed annually [S2]
Limits
- First-year prices are promotions; Pass Plus renews at $35.88 a year [S1]
- Free plan has no single-item sharing or built-in 2FA codes [S1]
- No Travel Mode listed on its plan pages [S1]
1Password
Visit 1Password (opens in a new tab)
Strengths
- Account password plus a 128-bit Secret Key that 1Password never receives [S8]
- Share any item by link with people who don't use 1Password, with expiry [S9]
- Travel Mode removes vaults not marked safe for travel from every device [S10]
- Business provisions users from Entra ID, Google Workspace, Okta and others [S4]
Limits
- No free plan, only a 14-day trial [S3]
- Costs more at every tier we compared [S1, S2, S3, S4]
- No email aliases listed on its plan pages [S3, S4]
FAQ
Questions people ask
Is Proton Pass as secure as 1Password?
Both encrypt your vault end to end with AES-25645. 1Password adds a 128-bit Secret Key to your account password, so a copy of its server data can’t be decrypted without that key8. Proton encrypts metadata such as usernames and web addresses as well as passwords, and publishes its app source code and audit reports5.
Is Proton Pass free?
How much cheaper is Proton Pass than 1Password?
Does 1Password have email aliases like Proton Pass?
Can I move from 1Password to Proton Pass?
Yes. Export a 1PUX file from the 1Password app on Mac, Windows or iOS. Then, in the Proton Pass browser extension, go to Settings > Import and choose 1Password (1pux, 1pif)12.
Sources
Sources
Small numbers in the text, like 1, point here. Each source shows the date we last checked it.
- 1Proton Pass pricing and plans (individuals)proton.me
- 2Proton Pass for Business plans and pricingproton.me
- 31Password personal pricing (Individual and Families)1password.com
- 41Password business pricing (Teams Starter Pack and Business)1password.com
- 5Proton Pass securityproton.me
- 6Proton Pass overviewproton.me
- 7Proton Pass hide-my-email aliasesproton.me
- 8About your Secret Key (1Password Support)support.1password.com
- 9Securely share 1Password items with anyone (1Password Support)support.1password.com
- 101Password Travel Mode1password.com
- 11Passkeys in 1Password1password.com
- 12How to import from 1Password to Proton Pass (Proton Support)proton.me
- 13Set up 1Password Unlock with SSO (1Password Support)support.1password.com
- 14Import passwords to Proton Pass (Proton Support)proton.me
Updated . See something out of date? Tell us and we will check it against the vendor's page.


